Quantum Milestone: Turning a Corner with Trapped Ions
When it comes to transporting ions, researchers at Quantinuum have turned a corner. Both literally and figuratively.
The Quantinuum team can now move two different types of ions through a junction in a surface trap, a tiny electrode-filled device at the heart of trapped ion quantum computers.
In a pre-print publication posted on arXiv, Quantinuum researchers outlined how they developed new waveforms that can guide a pair of ytterbium and barium ions through an intersection without the charged particles becoming overly excited or flying out of the trap.
The team tested the technique on a prototype trap with a grid-like architecture that Quantinuum has designed and microfabricated. This trap design will be a central part of future quantum computers such as the System Model H3.
This feat is an important breakthrough in the world of trapped ion quantum computing and for Quantinuum.
The ability to transport paired ions through a junction at the same time and intact is critical for scaling trapped ion systems. It’s also a longstanding technical challenge that trapped ion researchers in academia, government and industry have sought to solve for years.
“What Quantinuum has accomplished is a significant breakthrough for the field of trapped ion research and for our technology,” said Tony Uttley, president, and chief operating officer at Quantinuum. “This will enable us to deliver faster quantum computers with more qubits and fewer errors.”
Smooth transport of ions
Quantinuum’s technologies are based on the Quantum Charged Coupled Device (QCCD) architecture, a concept first introduced by the Ion Storage Group at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in the early 2000s.
Like other trapped ion technologies, this architecture relies on traps to capture ions in electric fields - or wells. Gates are performed on small chains of ions, which can be reordered and reconfigured within the architecture, enabling all-to-all connectivity.
In Quantinuum’s System Model H1 technologies, each well contains an ytterbium ion and a barium ion. The ytterbium ion functions as a qubit while the barium is cooled with a laser to reduce the motions of both ions, a technique known as sympathetic cooling. This cooling makes it possible to maintain low error rates in quantum computing operations for long calculations.
The H1-1 and H1-2 machines currently use a trap with a simple geometry or design that resembles railroad tracks. Wells of ions are moved back and forth along these linear tracks and swapped as needed to run an algorithm.
This linear design works well with fewer qubits. But it has limitations that make scaling difficult. Adding hundreds, much less thousands of qubits, would require the tracks to be much longer. It also would take more time to reposition and reset qubits.
To overcome these challenges, Quantinuum researchers have proposed moving to traps with more complex geometries. The System Model H2 will incorporate a racetrack-like design. The System Model H3 and beyond will use two-dimensional traps that resemble a city street grid with multiple railroad lines and intersections.
This design, however, also poses challenges. Getting those tracks to behave well at intersections is difficult and can jar ions and cause unwanted motion – especially those with different masses. It is somewhat like maneuvering a bullet train and allowing it to turn left or right at 90 degrees, or continue moving straight, without causing the cars to rock.
Quantinuum researchers were able to turn an ytterbium-barium ion pair around sharp corners with little motion. Until now, researchers envisioned having to separate paired ions and move them through junctions one a time, which would dramatically slow the operation. “To our knowledge, this is the first time any team has simultaneously moved two different species of ions through a junction in a surface trap,” said Dr. Cody Burton, a senior advanced physicist who worked on the project and lead author of the arXiv paper.
What’s next?
Researchers will continue to test and refine this new method.
Their goal is to expand from moving a single well to transporting several through multiple junctions at the same time. From there, they plan to incorporate this methodology into the System Model H3, which is expected to be the first Quantinuum quantum technology with the two-dimensional, grid-like trap.
“This new configuration will be key for scaling quantum computers in the hundreds, and then thousands, of high-fidelity qubits,” Uttley said. “While scaling, the qubits will maintain the high-quality characteristics such as low gate errors, long coherence times, and low cross-talk for which Quantinuum’s technologies are known.”
About Quantinuum
Quantinuum, the world’s largest integrated quantum company, pioneers powerful quantum computers and advanced software solutions. Quantinuum’s technology drives breakthroughs in materials discovery, cybersecurity, and next-gen quantum AI. With over 500 employees, including 370+ scientists and engineers, Quantinuum leads the quantum computing revolution across continents.
At this year’s Q2B Silicon Valley conference from December 10th – 12th in Santa Clara, California, the Quantinuum team will be participating in plenary and case study sessions to showcase our quantum computing technologies.
Schedule a meeting with us at Q2B
Meet our team at Booth #G9 to discover how Quantinuum is charting the path to universal, fully fault-tolerant quantum computing.
Join our sessions:
Tuesday, Dec 10, 10:00 - 10:20am PT
Plenary: Advancements in Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation: Demonstrations and Results
There is industry-wide consensus on the need for fault-tolerant QPU’s, but demonstrations of these abilities are less common. In this talk, Dr. Hayes will review Quantinuum’s long list of meaningful demonstrations in fault-tolerance, including real-time error correction, a variety of codes from the surface code to exotic qLDPC codes, logical benchmarking, beyond break-even behavior on multiple codes and circuit families.
Wednesday, Dec 11, 4:30 – 4:50pm PT
Keynote: Quantum Tokens: Securing Digital Assets with Quantum Physics
Mitsui’s Deputy General Manager, Quantum Innovation Dept., Corporate Development Div., Koji Naniwada, and Quantinuum’s Head of Cybersecurity, Duncan Jones will deliver a keynote presentation on a case study for quantum in cybersecurity. Together, our organizations demonstrated the first implementation of quantum tokens over a commercial QKD network. Quantum tokens enable three previously incompatible properties: unforgeability guaranteed by physics, fast settlement without centralized validation, and user privacy until redemption. We present results from our successful Tokyo trial using NEC's QKD commercial hardware and discuss potential applications in financial services.
Wednesday, Dec 11, 5:10 – 6:10pm PT
Quantinuum and Mitsui Sponsored Happy Hour
Join the Quantinuum and Mitsui teams in the expo hall for a networking happy hour.
Particle accelerator projects like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) don’t just smash particles - they also power the invention of some of the world’s most impactful technologies. A favorite example is the world wide web, which was developed for particle physics experiments at CERN.
Tech designed to unlock the mysteries of the universe has brutally exacting requirements – and it is this boundary pushing, plus billion-dollar budgets, that has led to so much innovation.
For example, X-rays are used in accelerators to measure the chemical composition of the accelerator products and to monitor radiation. The understanding developed to create those technologies was then applied to help us build better CT scanners, reducing the x-ray dosage while improving the image quality.
Stories like this are common in accelerator physics, or High Energy Physics (HEP). Scientists and engineers working in HEP have been early adopters and/or key drivers of innovations in advanced cancer treatments (using proton beams), machine learning techniques, robots, new materials, cryogenics, data handling and analysis, and more.
A key strand of HEP research aims to make accelerators simpler and cheaper. A key piece of infrastructure that could be improved is their computing environments.
CERN itself has said: “CERN is one of the most highly demanding computing environments in the research world... From software development, to data processing and storage, networks, support for the LHC and non-LHC experimental programme, automation and controls, as well as services for the accelerator complex and for the whole laboratory and its users, computing is at the heart of CERN’s infrastructure.”
With annual data generated by accelerators in excess of exabytes (a billion gigabytes), tens of millions of lines of code written to support the experiments, and incredibly demanding hardware requirements, it’s no surprise that the HEP community is interested in quantum computing, which offers real solutions to some of their hardest problems.
As the authors of this paper stated: “[Quantum Computing] encompasses several defining characteristics that are of particular interest to experimental HEP: the potential for quantum speed-up in processing time, sensitivity to sources of correlations in data, and increased expressivity of quantum systems... Experiments running on high-luminosity accelerators need faster algorithms; identification and reconstruction algorithms need to capture correlations in signals; simulation and inference tools need to express and calculate functions that are classically intractable.”
The HEP community’s interest in quantum computing is growing. In recent years, their scientists have been looking carefully at how quantum computing could help them, publishing a number of papers discussing the challenges and requirements for quantum technology to make a dent (here’s one example, and here’s the arXiv version).
In the past few months, what was previously theoretical is becoming a reality. Several groups published results using quantum machines to tackle something called “Lattice Gauge Theory”, which is a type of math used to describe a broad range of phenomena in HEP (and beyond). Two papers came from academic groups using quantum simulators, one using trapped ions and one using neutral atoms. Another group, including scientists from Google, tackled Lattice Gauge Theory using a superconducting quantum computer. Taken together, these papers indicate a growing interest in using quantum computing for High Energy Physics, beyond simple one-dimensional systems which are more easily accessible with classical methods such as tensor networks.
We have been working with DESY, one of the world’s leading accelerator centers, to help make quantum computing useful for their work. DESY, short for Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron, is a national research center that operates, develops, and constructs particle accelerators, and is part of the worldwide computer network used to store and analyze the enormous flood of data that is produced by the LHC in Geneva.
Our first publication from this partnership describes a quantum machine learning technique for untangling data from the LHC, finding that in some cases the quantum approach was indeed superior to the classical approach. More recently, we used Quantinuum System Model H1 to tackle Lattice Gauge Theory (LGT), as it’s a favorite contender for quantum advantage in HEP.
Lattice Gauge Theories are one approach to solving what are more broadly referred to as “quantum many-body problems”. Quantum many-body problems lie at the border of our knowledge in many different fields, such as the electronic structure problem which impacts chemistry and pharmaceuticals, or the quest for understanding and engineering new material properties such as light harvesting materials; to basic research such as high energy physics, which aims to understand the fundamental constituents of the universe, or condensed matter physics where our understanding of things like high-temperature superconductivity is still incomplete.
The difficulty in solving problems like this – analytically or computationally – is that the problem complexity grows exponentially with the size of the system. For example, there are 36 possible configurations of two six-faced dice (1 and 1 or 1 and 2 or 1and 3... etc), while for ten dice there are more than sixty million configurations.
Quantum computing may be very well-suited to tackling problems like this, due to a quantum processor’s similar information density scaling – with the addition of a single qubit to a QPU, the information the system contains doubles. Our 56-qubit System Model H2, for example, can hold quantum states that require 128*(2^56) bits worth of information to describe (with double-precision numbers) on a classical supercomputer, which is more information than the biggest supercomputer in the world can hold in memory.
The joint team made significant progress in approaching the Lattice Gauge Theory corresponding to Quantum Electrodynamics, the theory of light and matter. For the first time, they were able study the full wavefunction of a two-dimensional confining system with gauge fields and dynamical matter fields on a quantum processor. They were also able to visualize the confining string and the string-breaking phenomenon at the level of the wavefunction, across a range of interaction strengths.
The team approached the problem starting with the definition of the Hamiltonian using the InQuanto software package, and utilized the reusable protocols of InQuanto to compute both projective measurements and expectation values. InQuanto allowed the easy integration of measurement reduction techniques and scalable error mitigation techniques. Moreover, the emulator and hardware experiments were orchestrated by the Nexus online platform.
In one section of the study, a circuit with 24 qubits and more than 250 two-qubit gates was reduced to a smaller width of 15 qubits thanks our unique qubit re-use and mid-circuit measurement automatic compilation implemented in TKET.
This work paves the way towards using quantum computers to study lattice gauge theories in higher dimensions, with the goal of one day simulating the full three-dimensional Quantum Chromodynamics theory underlying the nuclear sector of the Standard Model of particle physics. Being able to simulate full 3D quantum chromodynamics will undoubtedly unlock many of Nature’s mysteries, from the Big Bang to the interior of neutron stars, and is likely to lead to applications we haven’t yet dreamed of.