Protecting Expressive Circuits with a Quantum Error Detection Code
Quantinuum has optimized the “iceberg” error detection code, opening the door to early fault-tolerant quantum computing
Detecting and correcting errors has become a critical area of development in quantum computing, a key that will unlock results which put quantum computers in a different league from their classical counterparts.
Researchers are working on ways to handle errors so that the hardware we will have in the coming months will be capable of performing useful tasks that are intractable for any classical computer — in other words, to achieve “quantum advantage”.
The full monty, known as “large-scale fault-tolerant quantum error correction” remains an open challenge in the quantum computing landscape, placing incredibly demanding constraints on the hardware. A promising start is to implement error detection instead of full error correction. In this approach, the system regularly checks for errors, and if one is detected, throws out the computation and restarts.
The team at Quantinuum realized that just such a code, nicknamed the “iceberg code”, if optimized to take advantage of the industry-leading components in Quantinuum’s trapped-ion quantum computers, could offer real potential for early fault-tolerance. Quantinuum’s H-Series hardware boasts mobile qubits, mid circuit measurement and the ability to program circuits with arbitrary-angle gates – making it ripe for new algorithm implementation and development. The team’s results, published today in Nature Physics Protecting expressive circuits with a quantum error detection code, detail a code that’s so efficient it was able to protect much deeper and more expressive circuits than had previously been realized with quantum error correction, and it did so making extremely efficient use of the very high-fidelity qubits and gates available in Quantinuum’s quantum charge-coupled device (QCCD) architecture.
“Our work sets the bar for what more advanced fully fault-tolerant codes need to beat on hardware,” said David Amaro, an author on the paper.
A key advantage of the iceberg code is how efficiently it squeezes out the maximum number of logical qubits from the given set of physical qubits – it can make k logical qubits out of only k+2 physical qubits. Every logical gate is implemented by a unique two-qubit physical gate, making it a very fast, clean, and expressive implementation. In addition to this, it needs only 2 more ancilla qubits for syndrome measurement, making for a very small overhead of only 4 physical qubits. Using the original 12-qubit configuration of Quantinuum’s H1-2 computer (since increased to 20), this meant the team could realize 8 logical qubits.
With these 8 logical qubits, the team implemented much deeper and more expressive circuits than had previously been demonstrated with quantum error correction codes.
The team’s work is the first experimental demonstration that sophisticated quantum error detection techniques are useful to successfully protect very expressive circuits on a real quantum computer. In contrast, previous demonstrations of fully fault-tolerant codes on hardware showed protection only of basic logical gates or “primitives” (the building blocks of full algorithms).
The Iceberg code is a method that’s useful today for practitioners, and can be used to protect near-term algorithms like the ‘quantum approximate optimization algorithm’, or the ‘variational quantum eigensolver’, algorithms currently put to work in domains including chemical simulation, quantum machine learning and financial optimization. In fact, it was used by a team at Quantinuum to protect the quantum phase estimation algorithm, a critical piece for many other quantum algorithms, and deployed in a state-of-the-art simulation of a real-world hydrogen molecule using logically-encoded qubits — a feat not possible using any other quantum computing hardware yet developed.
Looking forwards, the team plans to push the code as far as possible to determine if it is sufficient to protect quantum circuits capable of a quantum advantage. This will require setting a “minimal” quantum advantage experiment, working on careful engineering and benchmarking of every aspect of the code, and the use of Quantinuum’s best-in-class high fidelity gates. In parallel, they will also be working to understand if and how the Iceberg code can contribute to minimize the resource overhead of some of the most promising fully fault-tolerant codes.
About Quantinuum
Quantinuum, the world’s largest integrated quantum company, pioneers powerful quantum computers and advanced software solutions. Quantinuum’s technology drives breakthroughs in materials discovery, cybersecurity, and next-gen quantum AI. With over 500 employees, including 370+ scientists and engineers, Quantinuum leads the quantum computing revolution across continents.
Progressing your organization along the five levels of quantum maturity
Quantum computing has moved from a bet on the future to a race already underway. Early adopters are locking in strategic partnerships, building proprietary IP, and positioning themselves years ahead of competitors who are still watching from the sidelines. For executives, the question isn't whether to engage with quantum computing. It's how far along that journey your organization actually is, and what it takes to move forward.
That's a harder question to answer than it sounds. Quantum maturity isn't a single milestone you either hit or miss. It's a progression, built across talent, technology access, workflow integration, partnerships, and value realization, and most organizations aren't entirely sure where they currently stand and what to do next.
Our new paper, A Roadmap for Quantum Maturity, is built to answer exactly that.
A Framework for Where You Stand, and Where to Go Next
Drawing on extensive client experience, the paper lays out five distinct levels of quantum maturity, from early awareness through full transformation, along with the leadership actions that move an organization from one level to the next.
- Awareness — early conversations, but no clear ownership or use cases yet
- Exploration — exploring partnerships and prioritizing use cases with limited budget
- Experimentation — quantum roadmap established and guiding dedicated teams, funding, and partners to execute pilot use case projects
- Integration — quantum computing applications are being embedded into business unit workflows, and the quantum roadmap is integrated with broader digital technology strategy, including AI, HPC, and data
- Transformation — quantum capabilities are embedded in core products and decision-making, with differentiated, proprietary advantage
Most industry leaders today sit at the exploration or experimentation stages, with clear ambitions to reach transformation within the next several years. The paper breaks down what separates organizations that progress from those that stall out at proof-of-concept.
The Advantage Is Built, Not Bought
One of the paper's central takeaways is one many executives underestimate: investing in quantum technology alone isn't enough. Organizations that advance fastest pair that investment with a deliberate strategy, building quantum literacy across leadership and technical teams, honestly assessing capability gaps, focusing on a small number of high-impact use cases tied to real business metrics, and defining a clear roadmap that connects research to business advantage.
How Quantinuum Can Help
Achieving quantum maturity is a journey, not a single step, and most organizations don't need to make that journey alone. Quantinuum's consulting services are built to support every stage of it, from advisory and use-case identification, to capability building, technology access, and the co-development of scalable quantum solutions.
Whether your organization is just starting to build awareness or already scaling toward transformation, our team can help you identify exactly where you stand today, and what it takes to move to the next level.
- SoftBank Corp. and Quantinuum articulated a roadmap connecting quantum algorithms, hardware evolution, and commercial applications, helping organizations understand when quantum computing can address real-world challenges.
- The analysis demonstrates that quantum value will emerge in stages, with early opportunities in data analysis and longer-term breakthroughs in scientific computing as fault-tolerant systems mature.
- The work provides a practical planning framework for enterprises preparing to integrate quantum computing alongside AI and classical high-performance computing infrastructure in quantum-AI data centers.
Quantum computing is increasingly moving from exploratory discussion to structured enterprise planning. As organizations begin to assess where and when quantum technologies may deliver real business impact, a new class of work is emerging: integrated roadmaps that connect algorithmic feasibility, hardware development, and commercial opportunity.
A recent white paper from SoftBank Corp. and Quantinuum represents one of the most comprehensive examples of this approach to date. Rather than treating quantum computing as a distant, abstract capability, the study constructs a detailed, quantitative framework for understanding how real-world use cases evolve as hardware matures—and what this means for enterprise strategy.
A Comprehensive Roadmap
The SoftBank–Quantinuum white paper is broad in scope. It attempts to answer a fundamental question:
Which real-world problems can benefit from quantum computation, at what scale, with what accuracy requirements, and under what hardware conditions?
To address this, the study adopts a structured methodology that connects:
- Algorithmic resource estimates (logical qubits, circuit depth, gate counts)
- Explicit error correction assumptions and overhead models
- Hardware roadmaps across multiple generations
- Timelines for when specific classes of problems may become feasible
Two representative domains anchor the analysis:
- Quantum chemistry, particularly excited-state dynamics and photochemical processes
- Topological data analysis (TDA), including graph-based structure and anomaly detection
These domains were selected because they combine industrial relevance with computational structures that scale poorly on classical systems but map naturally onto quantum approaches.
Quantum chemistry is closely tied to materials science, energy systems, and the development of sustainable technologies. TDA, by contrast, offers tools for understanding complex data structures in networks, finance, and large-scale systems—where identifying structure and anomalies is increasingly critical.
Together, they illustrate how quantum computing may create value across both deep scientific domains and high-impact data applications.
An important caveat is that the resulting roadmap assumes a widely-studied but inefficient error correcting code. As more error correcting codes come online, the resources required to run algorithms will shrink. That means that the timelines detailed in this work can be thought of as “worst case” scenarios, which adds to the value by setting out a clear limit.
A distinguishing feature of the work is its emphasis on implementation over abstraction. Rather than relying solely on theoretical models, the study explicitly constructs quantum circuits and executes them on Quantinuum’s Helios and H2 system.
Parallel Paths to Value
A notable insight from the study is that quantum value creation will not follow a single linear path.
Instead, two complementary regimes are expected to emerge:
- In quantum chemistry, the focus is on fault-tolerant, logical-qubit-based computation, where error correction is essential for scaling toward meaningful scientific and industrial outcomes.
- In TDA, value can emerge earlier, where partial quantum advantage may already support useful computational tasks without full error correction.
This dual-track structure is important: it shows that quantum computing is not a single “threshold technology,” but a spectrum of capabilities that unlock value at different stages of maturity.
The Vision for Quantum Industrialization
The framework ultimately supports a broader strategic vision: the evolution of Quantum AI Data Centers—hybrid infrastructures where quantum processors operate alongside AI and classical HPC systems.
For enterprises, the implication is clear: quantum computing readiness is no longer about speculation. It is about structured preparation, disciplined modeling, and early engagement with the full stack of capabilities that will define the next generation of computational infrastructure.
Every year, The IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering – or IEEE Quantum Week – brings together engineers, scientists, researchers, students, and others to learn about advancements in quantum computing. This year’s conference, from September 13th - 18th in Toronto, Canada, will focus on translating research into real-world impact through the convergence of generative AI, distributed quantum systems, and quantum software engineering.
Throughout IEEE Quantum Week, our quantum experts will be on-site to share insights on upgrades to our hardware, enhancements to our software stack, our path to error correction, and more.
Meet our team at Booth #501 and join the below sessions to discover how Quantinuum is forging the path to fault-tolerant quantum computing with our integrated full-stack.
Keynote with Quantinuum's CEO, Dr. Rajeeb Hazra
September 14th
5:00 – 6:30pm | 800 Hall G
Quantum computing has passed the point where error correction is theoretical. What comes next depends on systems that hold logical performance steady and do real work at scale. On September 14th, join Quantinuum’s CEO Dr. Rajeeb Hazra for his keynote session on “Logically Speaking: The Next Era of Error Correction” where he will explore what the next era of quantum computing requires: shared definitions of logical performance, and benchmarks built on real workloads.
Speaking Sessions
September 13th
11:00 – 11:12am | Location: 601A/B
Workshop: QGenAI: Synergies between Quantum Computing and Generative Artificial Intelligence
Finding Compatible Datasets for Quantum Generative Modeling
Presenting Author: Chen-Yu Liu
September 14th
1:00 – 1:20pm | Location: 701B
Workshop: Q3-Control: Integrated Systems for Quantum Computing, Sensing, and Networking
Cryo-ASICs for Scalable Control
Speaker: Dr. Patty Lee
September 15th
2:30 – 3:30pm | Exhibit Hall (informal event)
Workshop: Q3-Control: Integrated Systems for Quantum Computing, Sensing, and Networking
The Quantum Spectrum
Speaker: Dr. Patty Lee
3:00 – 4:30pm | Location: 801A
Where Quantum-HPC Integration Actually Stands in 2026
Panelist: Neal Erickson
3:00 – 4:30pm | Location: 718A
From Research to Commercialization: Defining the Quantum Workforce for the Next Five Years
Panelist: Kortny Rolston-Duce
September 16th
10:00 – 11:30am | Location: 801B
Who Will Turn Quantum Computing into Value? Specialists, Domain Experts, and the Workforce Gap
Panelist: Enrico Rinaldi
September 17th
10:00 – 11:30am | Location: 701B
International Workshop on Quantum Computing for Power Systems: From Optimization Algorithms to Grid-Scale Applications | Session 1
Organizer: Kortny Rolston-Duce
10:00 – 11:30am | Location: 714A
openQSE: Co-Designing the Quantum-HPC Software Stack from Applications to Control Systems | Session 1
Speaker: Neal Erickson
10:00 – 11:30am
The Impact of Qubit Connectivity on Quantum Advantage in Noisy IQP Circuits
Presenting Author: Leonardo Placidi
10:15 – 11:00 am | Location: 601A/B
Workshop: AI for Circuit Synthesis, Optimization, and Discovery
Automated near-term quantum algorithm discovery
Speaker: Konstantinos Meichanetzidis
11:00 – 11:15am | Location: 601A/B
Workshop: AI for Circuit Synthesis, Optimization, and Discovery
Fast Stabilizer State Preparation via AI-Optimized Graph Decimation
Presenting Author: Jasmine Brewer
1:00 – 1:15pm | Location: 601A/B
Workshop: AI for Circuit Synthesis, Optimization, and Discovery
Reinforcement Learning for Adaptive Composition of Quantum Circuit Optimisation Passes
Speaker: Gabriel Matos
1:00 – 1:20am | 718B
Quantum Software 2.6: current challenges and headways in quantum software | Session 1
Quantum compilation and hybrid compilation
Speaker: Ross Duncan
1:00 – 2:30pm | Location: 714A
openQSE: Co-Designing the Quantum-HPC Software Stack from Applications to Control Systems | Session 2
Speaker: Phillipp Seitz
1:45 – 2:00pm | Location: 601A/B
Workshop: AI for Circuit Synthesis, Optimization, and Discovery
Graph-Theoretic Quantum Circuit Optimization with the ZX-Calculus and Gumbel AlphaZero
Speaker: Alexander Koziell-Pipe
2:00 – 2:15pm | Location: 601A/B
Workshop: AI for Circuit Synthesis, Optimization, and Discovery
Reusable Equivariant Neural Compilers for Matrix-Group Quantum Circuit Synthesis
Speaker: Richie Yeung
3:30 - 4:00pm | Location: 715B
Workshop: 4th Workshop on Quantum Computing for Natural Sciences: Technology and Applications
Quantum Algorithms
Speaker: Setso Metodi
September 18th
10:00 – 11:30am | Location: 801B
Scalable QPU architectures
Panelist: Setso Metodi